Toilet Repair

$50 Off Any Service Call

* Cannot be combined with other offers 

Toilet Repair Services

24/7 Emergency Services

Financing Available

Fully Licensed

717-229-0741

  Request Service

Hero Request Form

Fixing Your Broken Toilet With Ease

The older a toilet is, the more likely it is to develop problems like leaks or unusual noises. While most of these are minor annoyances, some can increase your water bill significantly, leaving behind a nasty mess, or even cause extensive water damage. If you are not sure what is causing a particular toilet problem, it is best to have a professional take a look.


At The Witmer Company, we have licensed, professional plumbers that can handle any toilet problem you may encounter, providing affordable, effective repairs in a minimal amount of time. We serve homeowners throughout the New Holland and Lancaster area, including Brownstown, Denver, Ephrata, Honey Brook, Morgantown, and the surrounding communities. Our expert plumbers are available 24/7 for emergency services, and our company also offers a complete selection of heating, air conditioning, and indoor air quality services.


Fill out our online form to schedule any of our plumbing services.

Common Toilet Problems That Need to Be Repaired

A toilet uses a combination of seals, valves, and other components to provide reliable, consistent operation. Worn seals, faulty valves, mineral accumulations, and other factors can all lead to malfunctions, and some of the most common toilet problems include:


  • Constantly running or noisy toilet – Mineral accumulation or a leaking flapper valve may allow water to drain from the tank to the bowl, creating a constant noise. A partially open supply valve may do the same.
  • Frequent clogs – If the water level in the tank is not high enough due to a defective or improperly adjusted float, the toilet may not flush properly. Other causes include flushing items other than waste or toilet paper, or a clogged vent.
  • Partial flushing – If the float or flapper chain is not adjusted properly, the toilet may not have enough water to flush correctly, or the tank may not empty completely.
  • Water leaks – Water on or near your toilet can be caused by loose supply hose fittings, a leaking tank seal, or a damaged tank.
  • Wastewater leaks – Leaks of wastewater may be caused by a defective wax ring or damaged toilet flange.
  • Odors – Persistent odors may indicate the trap is not holding water or the wax ring is leaking.


At The Witmer Company, we can repair these and numerous other toilet problems, and because we stock the most frequently needed replacement parts, many repairs can be completed on the first visit. Contact us today to schedule your toilet repairs. Emergency repairs services are available 24/7!

Toilet Repair Services From Your Local, Licensed Plumbers

Whether you have a simple toilet problem or something more complex, our team at The Witmer Company can repair it quickly and cost-effectively. Our toilet repair services include:


  • Replacing or repairing floats, flappers, and fill valves
  • Replacing or adjusting the flush handle, lever, and chain
  • Replacing wax rings or tank seals
  • Replacing supply valves, hoses, and seals
  • Replacing or repairing toilet flanges or drain lines
  • Removing clogs or foreign objects


If the toilet is cracked or otherwise beyond repair, we also offer toilet replacements.


From toilet repairs and installations to drain cleaning and general plumbing, you can count on The Witmer Company for all your plumbing and drain needs in the Lancaster and New Holland area.

Available 24/7 for Plumbing Emergencies

Call to Schedule Our Plumbing Services

(717) 229-0741

(717) 229-0741
hibu-tm

"We had a clog outside the house which was causing backups in the home to where we couldn’t use any water or toilets. We tried to get an emergency call last night from other companies and they either didn’t answer or couldn’t come till a few days out. So we looked outside of Ephrata area and found The Witmer Company.

We called and in less than an hour Keith came out and got our clog fixed in a half hour. Very affordable to come out and service will definitely be using this company for any and all future services with plumbing, heating and cooling."

- Ashley A via Google

Learn More About

The Witmer Company

Play Video
Share by: